Karaoke versions no longer stand in for the original
When a track was matched against Apple’s catalogue, a karaoke or
soundalike re-recording could occasionally win the match — and once it did, its
audio was what got analysed. You would get a normal-looking response with the right
title and often the right artist name, but the bpm, key,
energy and everything else described a different recording.
This was the worst-behaved miss in the matcher, because nothing about the response looked wrong. A karaoke release carries the correct title, is frequently credited to the original artist, and has a real preview to analyse. In the case that prompted the fix, the karaoke listing out-scored the genuine track.
These releases are now rejected during matching rather than scored down. If the real recording is available you get it as before; if it isn’t, you get an honest miss instead of another recording’s numbers. For anyone who wants the karaoke version, asking for it by its full title and label still returns it — the rule only applies when you didn’t ask for one.
- Detection is deliberately narrow, so ordinary tracks are unaffected: phrases like
“Originally Performed By”, “In the Style Of” and
“Backing Track”, or
karaokeinside a bracket. A song simply called “Karaoke”, or titles containing “tribute” or “cover”, are not treated as karaoke. - Across the current catalogue this classifies 0.05% of tracks — all of them from karaoke and backing-track labels.
- If a track you rely on starts returning a miss after this change, send it over — that would mean the match it was previously getting was a re-recording.